Evolution of Sleep
Summary
Questions
Evolution of Sleep
- Circadian rhythms
- Reptile sleep
- Proto-mammalian sleep
- Unihemispheric sleep in marine mammals and birds
- Dorsal and ventral streams and a proposal for the function of SWS.
- Conclusions
- Remaining questions
Evolution of Sleep
Circadian rhythms and clock genes
Questions:
- How does the clock work? A circular link of cause and effect.
- How is it brought in synchrony with the world?
- How does it bring about changes in behavior?
- Negative feedback loops involving transcription, translation and post-translational processes.
- Photoreceptors signal (synaptically in mammals, but not in birds) to the circadian oscillator, elevating the level of a clock component and thus resetting the clock.
- Output mechanisms vary across species. Protein level regulation by clock components.
Immortal time:
Circadian clock properties of rat suprachiasmatic cell lines
Earnest DJ, Liang FQ, Ratcliff M, Cassone VM
SCIENCE
283: (5402) 693-695 JAN 29 1999
Abstract:
Cell lines derived from the rat suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) were screened for circadian clock properties distinctive of the SCN in situ. Immortalized SCN cells generated robust rhythms in uptake of the metabolic marker 2-deoxyglucose and in their content of neurotrophins. The phase relationship between these rhythms in vitro was identical to that exhibited by the SCN in vivo. Transplantation of SCN cell lines, but not mesencephalic or fibroblast Lines, restored the circadian activity rhythm in arrhythmic, SCN-lesioned rats. Thus, distinctive oscillator, pacemaker, and clock properties of the SCN are not only retained but also maintained in an appropriate circadian phase relationship by immortalized SCN progenitors.
-
Barinaga M
Circadian rhythms - Clock photoreceptor shared by plants and animals
SCIENCE 282: (5394) 1628-1630 NOV 27 1998
How temperature changes reset a
circadian oscillator
Liu Y, Merrow M, Loros JJ, Dunlap JC
SCIENCE
281: (5378) 825-829 AUG 7 1998
Abstract:
Circadian rhythms control many physiological activities. The environmental entrainment of rhythms involves the immediate responses of clock components. Levels of the clock protein FRQ were measured in Neurospora at various temperatures; at higher temperatures, the amount of FRQ oscillated around higher Levels. Absolute FRQ amounts thus identified different times at different temperatures, so temperature shifts corresponded to shifts in clock time without immediate synthesis or turnover of components. Moderate temperature changes could dominate Light-to-dark shifts in the influence of circadian timing. Temperature regulation of clock components could explain temperature resetting of rhythms and how single transitions can initiate rhythmicity from characteristic circadian phases.
Natural variation in a Drosophila
clock gene and temperature compensation
Sawyer LA, Hennessy JM, Peixoto AA, Rosato E, Parkinson H, Costa R, Kyriacou CP
SCIENCE
278: (5346) 2117-2120 DEC 19 1997
Abstract:
The threonine-glycine (Thr-Gly) encoding repeat within the clock gene period of Drosophila melanogaster is polymorphic in length. The two major variants (Thr-Gly)17 and (Thr-Gly)20 are distributed as a highly significant latitudinal dine in Europe and North Africa. Thr-Gly length variation from both wild-caught and transgenic individuals is related to the flies' ability to maintain a circadian period at different temperatures. This phenomenon provides a selective explanation for the geographical distribution of Thr-Gly lengths and gives a rare glimpse of the interplay between molecular polymorphism, behavior, population biology, and natural selection.
Insect sleep?
- Bees show circadian periodicity in locomotor activity with a period slightly less than 24 hs. in the dark.
- Optomotor interneurons show circadian variability in response to pattern movement. Kaiser & Steiner-Kaiser, 1983.
The evolutionary picture
Fig. 51, Hobson 1995.
Ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny?
Mammalian babies from different species are more like each other than adults (
Figs. 7.8, 7.9 Horne).
Is REM, SWS or both homologous to reptile sleep?
No temperature regulation during REM sleep or reptile sleep.
Mammals and birds, both groups with distinct non-REM and REM sleep stages, are the homeothermic animals.
Non-REM in mammals is generated by the cerebrum, but reptiles have very little cerebrum.
However, there are electrical signs of non-REM sleep below the level of the cerebrum (‘limbic spike’ in amygdala). Hartse & Rechtschaffen found the limbic spike in basal ganglia of sleeping reptiles, and found that drugs that alter this spike activity in mammals seemed to have the same effect on the reptilian limbic spikes (in Siegel et al, 1998).
- Some reptiles (e.g. lizard, iguana (controversial)) show signs of REM sleep, including flat muscle tone and wake-like EEG activity (Peyrethon et al 1968, Huntley 1987, Ayala-Guerrero 1991; in Siegel et al, 1998).
Qs and As occupied 67.7% and 0.6% of the 24-h period, respectively. Each state displayed its own behavioral and electrophysiological characteristics. The mean duration of As episodes was very short (12.9 +/- 9 s). Stimuli reaction threshold was highest during sleep (Ayala-Guerrero 91).
Other reptiles (caimans) do not (Meglasson et al, 1979 in Siegel et al, 1998).
Evolution of Sleep in Mammals
- 3 main phylogenetic branches of mammals are placentals, marsupials and monotremes.
- In most placental and marsupial mammals, both SWS and REM sleep have been found.
- Echidna and platypus are only living monotreme species, a primitive branching of mammals.
- Echidna sleep,
first thought to show no REM (Allison et al, 1972), shares characteristics of REM & non-REM: brainstem activation and high amplitude EEG (Siegel et al, 1998).
- Platypus diverged from echidna 60-80 million yrs ago.
- Platypus exhibits 8 hs/day of REM sleep (
Fig. 5 Siegel 1998). REM scored by head and eye movements, heart rate pattern, despite high amplitude EEG.
In human neonates, REM does not entail reduction of high amplitude or increase in high frequencies in EEG (Emde & Metcalf, 1970 in Siegel et al, 1998).
What about marine mammals?
Unihemispheric Sleep
Marine mammals
- Marine mammals fall into 3 orders:
- Cetacea: dolphins and whales
- Sirenia: sea cows
- Pinnipedia: seals
- Cetacea and Sirenia live and sleep only in water; Pinnipedia live and sleep both in water and land.
- Dolphins must emerge at surface to breathe, and must therefore move permanently.
- Drug-induced BSWS causes breathing halt.
Fig. 7.1 Horne 1988 &/or Fig. 1 Mukhametov 1987.
Blind indus dolphin sleeps 7 hs a day in bouts of several seconds (Pilleri, in Horne 1988).
Asymmetrical sleep predominated in Amazonian dolphin (49% of day out of 57% of day taken by total sleep) (Mukhametov, 1987).
Behaviorally indistinguishable from symmetrical sleep.
No behavioral asymmetry noted.
Sleep deprivation of one hemisphere leads to compensation during recovery of that hemisphere only (Supin et al, 1978; Oleksenko et al, 1992).
No REM seen in adult dolphins (Mukhametov in Horne 1988).
REM observed in elephant seal pups (Castellini et al, 1994).
One report observed USWS in whales too (Serafetinides et al, 1972).
Dolphins have complete optical decussations and poorly developed corpus callosum (cc). Is this the unihemispheric sleep enabler?
- Unihemispheric sleep occurs in birds with binocular vision.
- Unihemispheric sleep is also observed in regions below the hemispheres (e.g. the thalamus).
- Opposum and other mammals with poorly developed cc have no unihemispheric sleep.
- Mammals with severed cc carry on with bihemispheric sleep.
- The amazonian manatee (Sirenia) shows SWS for 27% and paradoxical sleep for 1% of recording time.
- Paradoxical sleep was identified as flat neck EMG with desynchronized EEG. No REM or muscle twitches were found.
- These periods were 20-253 s long.
- 25% of SWS was asymmetrical.
- Sleep was briefly interrupted to breathe.
- Some seals show USWS; others do not. Seals show prolonged (15-30 mins) breath holding during sleep.
Birds
- 17% of sleep in the glaucous winged gull is USWS (Amlaner et al, in Horne 1988).
- Unihemispheric sleep in ducks is accompanied by asynchronous contralateral eye closure (Rattenborg et al, 1999).
- Perhaps used in transoceanic flights, although this remains untested (Rattenborg, personal communication).
References
AYALA-GUERRERO F, HUITRON-RESENDIZ S (1991): SLEEP PATTERNS IN THE LIZARD CTENOSAURA-PECTINATA. PHYSIOLOGY & BEHAVIOR 49: (6) 1305-1307.
- CASTELLINI MA, MILSOM WK, BERGER RJ, COSTA DP, JONES DR, CASTELLINI JM, REA LD, BHARMA S, HARRIS M (1994): PATTERNS OF RESPIRATION AND HEART-RATE DURING WAKEFULNESS AND SLEEP IN ELEPHANT SEAL PUPS. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSIOLOGY 266: (3) R863-R869, Part 2.
Kushida, Bargmann and Rechtschaffen (1989): Sleep deprivation in the rat. IV. Paradoxical sleep deprivation. Sleep 12, 22.
Mukhametov (1987): Unihemispheric slow-wave sleep in the Amazonian dolphin, Inia geoffrensis. Neurosci Lett 79, 128.
Oleksenko, Mukhametov et al (1992). Sleep Research 1, 40.
- Serafetinides et al (1972): Int'l Journal of Psychobiol. 2, 129.
- Siegel et al (1998): Monotremes and the evolution of rapid eye movement sleep. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. B 353, 1147.
- Supin … & Mukhametov (1978): Electrophysiological study of dolphins brain.