Monday, September 13, 2010

Dhobi Ghat Review




Dhobi Ghat is the story of 4 characters: Arun, the famous lonely painter (Aamir), Munna, the dhobi who wants to be a star (Prateik), Shai, the banker on a sabbatical in India (Monica) and Yasmin, the recently married Muslim girl who records her life in Mumbai for her brother back home (Kriti). They say that Mumbai is the fifth character in the movie, and if so, I found it to be a silent character, an immovable witness to the harmony and turmoil in which the characters function simultaneously. Much like the aunty in Arun's neighbouring apartment: always there, always seeing everything, but always silent. Not sure if that was a parallel that Kiran had in mind, but it seemed relevant to me.


The movie is a piece of their lives, and the narrative juggles a recent past and the present time beautifully. Among the daily routine of the characters, which is really what the story is about, we see a love story unfolding and it's not a love triangle but a love square. With a missing fourth connecting line. I swear I'm not trying to sound cryptic, but it's so charming to watch this play out that I don't want to spoil it for anyone.

So maybe I won't tell the story after all...

But I will highlight the three superstars of this movie, and neither of their names start with two Aa's.


First of all KIRAN RAO.


Tiny little thing, with such a big heart! And this picture captures everything that is adorable about her! But I won't ramble about that now. I had no doubt that she would make a good movie, I knew it would be a well thought out story. What I didn't know was that she would wow me with the little touches like a bunch of fake grapes hanging from the rear view mirror in a car during the monsoon, which is the opening shot of the film. Or the chance encounter between Shai and Arun in the street when Shai is on her way to literally stalk Arun in his apartment which is so subtle and funny in so many ways. Or the painting that Arun makes towards the end of the film (who made that? I want it!). Or the old neighbour sitting in her chair with a vacant look - the most powerful image in the whole movie in my opinion. Or Munna leaning over Shai when she's asleep. Or the women on the train that Yasmin is filming. I could go on... but then I'd just be telling the whole movie. Suffice to say that every single shot in this movie tells a story, every image counts, and that is no small feat for a first time director.

When I heard that Dhobi Ghat was being filmed guerrilla style, with handheld cameras and moving shots, I was a bit terrified, because there's a right way to do this, but mostly I've seen it done the wrong way. Kiran, thankfully, got it right and I cannot praise her enough for this!

Secondly PRATEIK (BABBAR).

 At the end of the screening when Aamir gave the mic to each of the actors to say a few words, before Prateik even touched the mic he got a long, loud, standing ovation from the audience. He was so shocked and overwhelmed that he literally was speechless. He tried to mumble a thank you to Kiran and I bet he would have had some very heartfelt words to say, but he was so choked up that he didn't manage to put two words together. It was beyond charming!!

Well, he stole the show, it's no secret. He had the audience's emotions in the palm of his hand: when he wanted us to laugh at his shyness, we did; when he wanted us to bite our fingers for his next move, we did; when he wanted us to be in love with him, we were; when he wanted us to pine with him, we did. An outstanding performance if I've ever seen one! Between Kiran's deeply intelligent script and Prateik's immensely intuitive acting, there was not much room for it to get better. 

And still it did, because then there's...


THE STORY.

It's been said enough times by now that this is not a Bollywood story. But I don't think that stops it from being an Indian story, and if Bollywood continues to do stories like this, then I am on board with this new wave of what Cameron Bailey reluctantly jokingly calls "hindie movies". In a way I can't help but compare Dhobi Ghat to Slumdog Millionaire because they both show various aspects of poverty in Mumbai. But Dhobi Ghat succeeds for me where Slumdog somewhat failed because it shows me the little things that make one happy despite the poverty, unlike Slumdog which was always focused on wanting more. Munna has his own world with its ups and downs, with things that make him sad and things that make him smile, but his life does not revolve around poverty, his life revolves around his feelings, as it should.

And I know I tend to talk more about Munna than about everyone else because he was the star of the show for me, followed closely by Yasmin's story, but make no mistake, this movie is about all four of them in equal measure. More importantly, this is a story about people. It's not about lessons learned or growing up, it's not about relationships created or maintained, it's not about finding yourself, it's not about careers or hobbies. It's just a series of snapshots of 4 people... living. And while that can sound boring, it's really not, because the film is so well crafted that much like in real life when someone is telling a good story, you keep asking: "and then what?"

And lastly AAMIR KHAN.

Without presuming to know what's really in this man's head, I will say that I think I know why Aamir so badly wanted to be in this movie instead of letting Kiran pick another fresh face. In a world where Om Shanti Om, Ghajini and 3 Idiots are blockbusters, a soulful movie like Kiran's would have probably gone unnoticed had it not been for the presence of her superstar husband. Sad, but true... At the same time, I appreciated that Aamir played the part in such a subtle way that, much like in Taare Zameen Par, Aamir The Actor was rightfully overshadowed by his costar and by the director. I know he could have made this his movie, but there's a reason why he didn't, there's a reason why he played the part that many other actors could have played without making it an Aamir exclusive role, and I like to think that generosity and love are that reason.

I won't give a rating to this movie because as I said, Dolce was left at home (actually I suspect she was one of the people who mobbed Aamir on the street there and then she probably snuck into the theatre and saw the movie anyway), but I will say: don't miss this when it comes out in theatres!

51 comments:

  1. Thats a nice review, seems like a great movie, but honestly, I do not read too much in fan reviews since they are all.... fans...

    Anyhow, early review is up

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fan reviews and "critics" reviews are the same thing for Midget Khan. :D I remember reviews of Fanaa and Ghajini and shiver.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh well, that is so true. Right now its kinda hip

    ReplyDelete
  4. i cant wait to see this movie i am very excited waiting for the time to come

    ReplyDelete
  5. "They say that alcohol kills slowly. So what? Who's in a hurry ?".Catch more quotations and share with millions on facebook on:-
    http://www.desilikes.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. yeah, love listening to your collection of songs at any time of the day, guys if wanna listen to your songs visit:-
    http://www.ganeshane.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. One of the song background score copied from Landramout blues by Albert. Movie is a mixture of Hollywood movies Dirty Laundry + Things Asian + others with some Indian essence. Cheap Trick by Amir & Kiran

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have not heard the original so I cannot say. Maybe you should suggest to Milliblog that he compare the two...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Isn't the music by Gustavo Santaolalla not Pritam?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Haaha..I am just alluding to most BW composers(Pritam is just a placeholder). It is possible this guys also steals but likelihood of that would be comparatively very less :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. That is why I suggested Milliblog as the person who can get to the bottom of the issue.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I m sure it will be another 100 Crore+ movie in Box Office. Reason I say this just because this movie has a name "Aamir Khan (The Magician!)" attached to it.

    My advise is "Do not miss to watch this movie"

    Raj

    ReplyDelete
  13. Maybe I need to start a prediction thread for Dhobi Ghaat now! :D

    ReplyDelete
  14. Amir Khan is good actor, dhobi ghat movie reviews very nice, hello everyone - Do not miss to watch this movie

    ReplyDelete
  15. Dont worry Way 2 Read News - Even the people who generally dont like him or bash him, end up watching his movies in theatre :)

    Now isnt that something.

    ReplyDelete
  16. http://dolcenamak.blogspot.com/2010/09/namak-went-to-see-dhobi-ghat-at-tiff.html

    ReplyDelete
  17. wow.... the way the review has been written is superb, was so catchy. i hope the movie aswell is ;)

    ReplyDelete
  18. Aamir Khan. That's enough to watch the movie. If you miss it you will be called the 4th biggest idiot of the universe.

    Aamir Khan is simply Better than the Best.

    ReplyDelete
  19. @ Anonymous - who r first 3 Idiots ?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Of course number 1 is Aamir, then Madhavan and then Sharman Joshi ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  21. wud be a rocking one

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anon - we get it dude, rocking good.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Its akinda movie one will have to watch with intent, its not gonna be the movie that will be imbibed by many, its the tester for audience as well as to how they are moved after this breath taking reality in the movie.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I have a short attention span :-P

    ReplyDelete
  25. m going for partiek

    ReplyDelete
  26. the movie's incomplete. you feel like the movies about to start with its story and all, and thats when the credits start! the movie was very "bland", i'd say. it felt like i was just looking out my window on a rainy day, and i could've spotted any of these stories in my neighborhood. its pretty boring honestly. prateik was very cute though :) great acting.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Hey thanks for visiting guys! Do check out the consolidated reviews on main page also

    ReplyDelete
  28. kya bakwass movie hai theater mai dekh ke paise or time dono bigadha

    ReplyDelete
  29. its not a superhit movie for people who r accustomed to watch gana n dance n twists! its an art movie! it touches your heart n invades ur mind! i been thinking ab it since i watched it! i dun expect all my friends to like it! but i loved it! i was lookin forward to one such movie and been missin such kind of artistic piece n m glad i watched it! it goes slow, but it makes u to feel for the characters and help u empathise with them! i know there were people sitting in cinema who kept talking( one of the couple was kicking our chair)! and a guy was snoring next to me, but for those who love subtle things, and have respect for good cinema! its a movie for them!

    ReplyDelete
  30. this movie sucks ......

    ReplyDelete
  31. advice me whether to watch or not .......

    ReplyDelete
  32. It is slow, it is moody, it is not always consistent, two actors are good, two are just about OK, but I thought it was a decent watch

    ReplyDelete
  33. title is misleading. different but not a movie with strong concept.

    ReplyDelete
  34. this is great movie,it really is, believe me if aamir is gonna do any of this kinda thing , he will be known as BEST actor of indian cinema ever!
    truly nice movie, shows what it has to show and well awesomely shows it. General public will find it boring cause 90 % of those are on earth for fapping and having food no matter what matters to them

    ReplyDelete
  35. Really good insights! I didn't find enough people who remembered a lot of detail from the film. Even if they did, the metaphors apparently did not manifest themselves. Dhobi Ghat will most certainly polarize the audience. I wrote a detailed review here, http://bit.ly/hW2SB9. Please read and share if you like it!

    ReplyDelete
  36. worst movie.. aint worth seeing

    ReplyDelete
  37. DHOBI GHAT.....the film projects out the nacked truth of life.......its shows pains...agonies.....dissapointmnt....of some unspeakbl emotns....some futile dreams...a tormentabl past...and at the end a painful realizatn of truth...it is a true portrait of reality....it doesnt creat illusions..bt breaks dem...the film is not beauty but truth...And what is more beautiful than truth itself?...DHOBI GHAAT is not an art for the sake of art..its an ART FOR THE SAKE OF LIFE..

    ReplyDelete
  38. hopeless movie.. pls dont make such movie pls....

    ReplyDelete
  39. Art film made by a novice!

    ReplyDelete
  40. Collection of events where some events are like scattered flowers around flower pot… – Manish Jaiswal

    ReplyDelete
  41. this movie is not meant for those who like only freaky comedy and actions of bollywood...those who commented this movie as 'bakwas' or something like that,will never understand the depth of this movie, no matter how much you try.....how come you like 'dhobi ghat' when you loved the so called 'dabaang' so much...
    IT IS INDEED A VERY GOOD AND A MUST WATCH MOVIE......imdb doesn't give 7.8 just like that....

    ReplyDelete
  42. I am sick and tired of people judging other people's tastes. Tell us what you liked in the film and why, do not judge why I may not have liked this or any other film.

    ReplyDelete
  43. @ Anonymous: As i mentioned earlier, no matter how much i try to explain, you will never understand. So do not comment if you don't have enough knowledge in a particular topic.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Uttam: Don't know about anon, but actually it might help me if you did explain. I would like to know what particular topic you are talking about. To help you along another review is at LINK

    ReplyDelete
  45. Flop - Total flop (In my honest view). Could not understand why it ended the way it did - I thought it was intermission at first. What exactly was the role of that old lady - hmm? I am still trying to figure out what the story line was. Waste of money for watching in theatre. I think reviews are incorrectly hyped. I do liked all the actors, just could not get into the movie. Yogesh Halai.

    ReplyDelete
  46. I am not sure how one can not fall in love with this movie and its cast. The story is so simple yet so spell binding. I only i wish i had more flowery words to describe this Oscar worthy movie.
    To all the guys who have declared this a flop / total disaster etc... i suggest you stick with Om Shanti Om, Hunter wali, Yamala Paagal Deevana kind of movies.

    Why worry about masterpeice movies like this :)

    ReplyDelete
  47. You are right anon - many did not worry about this "masterpiece", that is why it would up in the second week itself...

    ReplyDelete
  48. haha..we don't know, are these anon same or different. Guys please use some name :)

    ReplyDelete
  49. We jump from anon to anon - nameless faceless people, talking about identity in a city where people are nameless and faceless..

    ReplyDelete
  50. any how definitely i watch the movie soon.............

    ReplyDelete